• Best CPA Networks
  • Best Cost-Per-Sale Affiliate Networks
  • Best Pay-Per-Call Networks
  • mThink Digital
  • Thought Leadership
    • White Papers
  • About
    • Content Marketing
    • Content Strategy
      • Web Content
      • Social Media Strategy
      • Webinars & Video
      • Thought Leadership
    • Performance Marketing
    • Portfolio
      • Revenue Performance
      • Accenture
      • Microsoft
      • Java Detour
      • Our Process
    • Contact Us

mThink

Blue Book Logo

BlueBook Logo

The Trusted Name in Performance Marketing

ROS Leaderboard

  • Home
  • Blue Book
    • About Blue Book
    • Blue Ribbon Panel
    • Interviews
    • Research Methodology
    • Back Issues
    • Advertising
      • Website Creative Specifications
      • Newsletter Creative Specifications
  • Best CPA Networks
  • Best Cost-Per-Sale Affiliate Networks
  • Best Pay-Per-Call Networks
  • Best European CPA Networks
  • Best CPA Networks for Affiliates
  • Best CPA Networks for Advertisers

CFPB Issues Warning About Contractual Gag Clauses and Consumer Reviews

April 3, 2022 by Richard B. Newman

On March 22, 2022 the CFPB issued a policy statement on contractual “gag” clauses and fake review fraud.  While the bulleting indicates that financial companies will face consequences for illegally manipulating or suppressing consumer reviews, the message is one with broader implications for all digital marketers.

The policy guidance regarding potentially illegal practices related to consumer reviews seeks to ensure that customers can write reviews, particularly ones posted online, about financial products and services that accurately reflect their opinions and experiences.  The guidance also highlights that practices such as posting fake reviews or inserting clauses that forbid a customer from publishing an honest review may violate the Consumer Review Fairness Act.

“In America, no corporation should be able to silence a customer from posting an honest review online,” said CFPB Director Rohit Chopra.  “Corporate disinformation campaigns that suppress legitimate reviews or manufacture fake reviews are not only a threat to free speech and fair competition, they are also illegal.”

The CFPB’s guidance describes certain business practices related to customer reviews that are generally unlawful under the Consumer Financial Protection Act, including: (i) Contractual ‘gag’ clauses: attempting to silence consumers from posting an online review can undermine fair competition.  Banks and financial companies that include clauses in form contracts that forbid a consumer from posting an honest review may be engaged in unfair or deceptive practices; (ii) Fake Reviews: Markets can be harmed if consumers cannot trust that online reviews are legitimate.  Laundering fake reviews in ways that appear completely independent from the company to improve their ratings may constitute a deceptive practice; and (iii) Review Suppression or Manipulation: Consumers cannot easily shop and compare products and services when firms engage in practices to limit the posting of negative reviews or manipulate reviews to trick or confuse consumers.

Importantly, companies can engage in unfair, deceptive and abusive acts and practices by manipulating consumers’ understanding of consumer reviews by, for example: (i) instructing employees to leave reviews of its products on a third-party website, and also to ”dislike” negative reviews left by genuine customers; and failing to approve or publish hundreds of thousands lower-starred, more negative reviews.

The CFPB’s policy statement is related to the efforts taken by the Federal Trade Commission in order to deter fake reviews and related fraud across the digital economy.  In fact, the FTC recently voted  to put hundreds of businesses on notice about fake reviews and misleading endorsements, which may result in significant penalties against marketers that engage in this misconduct.

Banks and financial companies should also ensure that their customer review practices comply with all applicable laws, including the Consumer Financial Protection Act.  Violations are subject to civil penalties and other legal consequences.

Regardless of the specific vertical, digital marketers should consider consulting with an experienced FTC attorney in order to design and implement best practices, including, but not limited to, responsible contracting, and ensuring first and third party compliance with FTC endorsement guidance.

Richard B. Newman is an FTC attorney  at Hinch Newman LLP. He represents digital marketers that are subject to FTC CID investigations and enforcement actions. Follow him on Twitter at FTC defense lawyer.

Informational purposes only. Not legal advice. May be considered attorney advertising.

 

Related posts:

  1. FTC Rules With Civil Monetary Penalties for Deceptive Earnings Claims and Targeted Marketing May Be Forthcoming Accountable Tech has recently filed a petition for an FTC...
  2. Breaking News: Supreme Court Limits Regulatory Right to Disgorgement in Judicial Enforcement Actions On June 22, 2020, the Supreme Court issued its highly...
  3. California Redefines Analysis of Independent Contractor Classification In September 2019, California Governor Gavin Newsom signed a new...
  4. Court Addresses Unconstitutional TCPA Damages and Who Can be Held Liable A company that managed the ownership rights of a film...

Filed Under: Blue Book, Revenue, Revenue Blog Tagged With: CFPB, Ftc attorney, FTC defense lawyer

Search

ROS Col 2 Top

ROS Col 2 Mid

ROS Col 2 Low

Subscribe to our newsletter!

* indicates required

ROS Col 2 – 4 Misc

ROS Col 2 – 5 Misc

ROS Col 2 – 6 Misc

Recent Posts

  • 2023: Challenges, Opportunities & Predictions
  • Top 4 Best Practices For Consumer Finance Campaigns
  • Four Moments That Changed Performance Marketing Forever
  • New additions, improvements, and added perks from your favorite CPA network
  • Your Top 5 Affiliate Marketing Questions Answered
  • 5 strategies to create better content
  • FCC Says Ringless Voicemails Require Prior Consent
  • Top 5 Free Methods to Increase Affiliate Traffic
  •  3 Top Lead Generation Best Practices To Scale Your Business
  • Automation, Conversions, Profitability, Oh My – Breaking Affiliate Campaign Roadblocks
  • 5 tips for a better brand image
  • How Mac of All Trades Found Multi-Channel Success
  • Winning In A Changing World: An Interview with Taras Kiseliuk, CEO of ClickDealer
  • Survey: What Consumers Want from Financial Services Providers
  • The influencer marketing era: what does the future of web marketing hold?

About mThink

mThink is a specialist digital marketing company based in San Francisco. We focus on media buying, Facebook marketing, direct response, social and mobile. In addition mThink produces the annual Blue Book Rankings of major performance marketing networks. Read More »

Baseboard

Copyright ©2023 · mThink. All rights reserved.
3053 Fillmore Street, Suite 325 | (415) 787-0250
Disclaimer | Privacy Policy