So Now Youre In-Charge of an Unregulated Generation Company by Chris Trayhorn, Publisher of mThink Blue Book, November 15, 2000 You’ve probably just been named to head an acquired portfolio of generation assets. Or maybe you’re one of the visionaries who “led” your company through the regulatory hurdles of forming an unregulated generation company affiliate. Either way, your formula for future success has evolved – you’re now a part of industry in general. Your chairman and shareholders expect you to be profitable and produce value – now. Sure, they realize you still have to maintain a reliable generation system and that you have an obligation to serve, potentially as the provider of last resort. However, that’s your worry, not theirs. They are focused on profitability and cash flow, as they should be, given the level of capital invested in your company. Weren’t you the one that pushed for competition? Weren’t you the one that said, “Our world is changing, and we need to be ahead of the curve and the rest of the industry?” Weren’t you the insightful, outspoken advocate of the benefits of competition among your management team? Yes, you were and now, as your reward, you’re the person in charge in this new environment. What will you do? How do you make your new company successful? This white paper is going to give you some guidance on how to energize (excuse the pun) your company’s performance. The changes that need to be made are dramatic, difficult, and most importantly, involve you. You’ll have to work hard, and you may not have all the answers. That’s okay – your people expect this to be a learning process. Your shareholders, on the other hand, don’t expect it to be a long process. Transcending “Old School” Your employees are ready and willing for you to lead them. Many of these people have been waiting their entire careers for an opportunity to prove that they can compete and that their facilities can be successful in an open market. However, one problem may exist – you aren’t sure of their abilities in such an environment. You might lament, “Where can I get the right kind of employees for a competitive marketplace?” Your current employees were just recently regulated generation employees (never mind that both you and I came from the utility industry as well). Some may suggest that they’re “old school.” In other words, they don’t know the first thing about competition. They’re accustomed to a cost-plus perspective. They don’t know how to be efficient because they’ve never had to be. Well, you’re partially right. You do need some new team members. But it’s not new employees that you need – it’s “new” management. You’re the problem. Yes, you’re the biggest single hurdle to your new company’s success. Quit scoffing, I’m dead serious. You have to change. Most of what you believe, particularly as it relates to managing your new company, needs to be thrown out the window. The insight and acumen you acquired working your way up the corporate ladder in a regulated utility doesn’t work very well in a competitive company. Trust me. Rules for Success Instead, there are some new basic rules for success. These are fundamentals, for lack of a better term, that many regulated utility managers have forgotten over the years. Rule #1: Trust Your Employees They know what they’re doing. Give them latitude. Allow them to have more decision-making authority than you feel comfortable giving. Toss aside the old utility perspective that senior management can trust its employees only after they have proved they can be trusted. This naïve and negative way of thinking may have caused more harm to your company than any other innate characteristic of management. You’ve probably always wondered why your employees didn’t have a lot of trust in management. Well, it’s because management never trusted its employees. If you want to forever correct this situation, you and your managers must change. Sever all of your managers that you don’t trust first. Until your employees really believe that you trust them to do the right things, they won’t contribute to the company’s performance improvements. It’s a domino effect – one executive demonstrating mistrust will affect the image of all managers including you personally. Rule #2: Care for Your Employees Your primary responsibility as the leader of your company is to take care of your employees. Your employees need to be well-trained, well-compensated, and treated with respect. Encourage your employees to have a healthy balance between professional and personal responsibilities. If you are the 80-hours-a-week, work-until-midnight type of manager (and many of us have been given all the new demands of deregulation), stop now. Common sense tells you that your effectiveness is directly related to your personal well-being, and no one can be at his or her best when they’re burning the candle at both ends. Your employees will emulate senior management’s practices; therefore, if you work 80-hour weeks, so will they. Burn-out, poor employee morale, and high turnover will be the result. Lead by example and show your employees that spending time with family and friends is at least as important as working hard. Train your employees, encourage them to attend post-graduate education programs – and pay for it. The value created by having smarter employees more than offsets the cost of funding additional education. Seeking knowledge is a trait that you must foster with your people. Elevating the company’s intellectual capital will, in turn, bolster its overall performance. Each of us knows we have only a few truly good ideas a year and, if your company is going to succeed in a new marketplace, you need to increase the number of employees generating good ideas. Quality, post-graduate education will lead to good ideas from your employees. Compensate your employees with motivation in mind. This doesn’t mean you have to be top tier from a total compensation perspective. It does mean, however, that you have to essentially make compensation a non-issue. Provide fair base salaries and larger incentive opportunities than you were accustomed to in the regulated utility industry. Cash is king, and your short-term incentive programs should be laden with cash rewards. Give your employees the opportunity to win large bonuses, and they will produce big results to earn them. Also, don’t falsely assume that your employees don’t care about the long-term performance of the company. The fact is they probably have a greater vested interest in it than you do. They’re neither as mobile, nor as sought-after by competitors, as you are. Given this fact, allow your employees access to wealth creation tied to the company’s success by more broadly providing stock options. And don’t stop the small recognition programs that your company may have had in place, either. You know the kind that I mean – an employee reaches an important goal, gets his or her picture in the company newsletter, and receives a company logo paperweight or pin. Eliminating these programs and gestures sends the wrong message that small contributions don’t matter. On the contrary, in our business, as in any commodity-driven marketplace, routinely being able to hit singles produces a lot more runs than the occasional home run (unless you’re Mark McGwire, of course). Therefore, recognition for small successes becomes even more important as the company moves toward its new structure. Treat your employees with respect and value their time as if it were your own. Your employees are the company “doers.” Every time you inadvertently miss a meeting, postpone a discussion, or don’t have time to review a document, your company is losing valuable “doing” time. Remember, because we’re encouraging our employees to have a healthy balance between work and family, lost productivity is worth even more in a competitive environment. Likewise, don’t dominate interactions with employees. They know your way of thinking and beliefs. It’s been splashed all over the company through newsletters, press releases, and other company materials. Instead, listen to your employees. Focus on their ideas and feedback. Set a goal for yourself of trying to leave each employee meeting with a new piece of information – how the company performs, what your employees think about a situation, or how you might improve your own performance. If you pay attention to what your employees are saying, there will be at least one new performance improvement opportunity embedded in their comments. Most employees are quite adept at identifying areas where senior management needs to improve and at conveying their opinions in a politically correct manner. All we have to do is listen and the message will be there. Rule #3: Focus On Results Utilities are well-known for their ability to over-analyze, study, and research an issue. The running joke in the industry is that this tendency produces the “paralysis by analysis” mentality. It doesn’t matter if this perception is factually based or relates to your old way of doing business (of course, your former company didn’t have this reputation – it was the “other guy”). You and your company have to move quickly. You can’t be fascinated with the “process of the process.” Believe it or not, this quarter’s results are less than 90 days away, and your chairman and shareholders are expecting you to perform again, remember? A big part of your focus on results will be access to financial information when you need it, and that means as close to real-time as possible. If your generation portfolio is going to be selling predominantly into merchant markets, I can’t foresee any way that you could effectively monitor your performance without daily gross margin reports. Daily reports? Absolutely. You have to know from day-to-day how much production you had, at what price you sold it, and how you stand relative to that month’s approved plan. I realize that this is foreign to a traditional utility’s accounting and reporting group whose typical close is measured in weeks versus days, let alone hours. Additionally, you need to monitor your Operations & Maintenance and General & Administrative expenses on a real-time basis. The nimblest competitors in this new generation marketplace live and breathe their margin and cost information, and use it to their advantage. You’re producing and selling a commodity in a competitive market that oftentimes is not as efficient as it should be – knowing your margin and cost positions can guide your asset managers in determining how best to position your assets, both from a capacity and energy perspective. Another important element for a successful future is transforming the pace at which business is conducted. You need to establish a sense of urgency. How do you accomplish this? Demonstrate your willingness to make a decision in a situation when you have only 60 percent of the required information. I know that this is the antithesis of every experience in a career characterized by public utility commissions (PUC) habitually re-evaluating major company decisions. Surprise – the PUCs are also changing. They realize that an “after-the-fact” approach will jeopardize their very existence. They know that companies need to be more responsive and free to act competitively. The PUCs recognize which way the winds of deregulation are blowing just like you do. Remember, it’s this same PUC and commission staff that had the foresight to approve your spinning off the utility’s generation assets into an unregulated affiliate or allow the sale of these assets to an independent third party, like your company, in the first place. When you adopt this “60 percent and go” policy, you need to be prepared for what will inevitably happen. Your company will make mistakes. In fact, your company will make a lot of mistakes. Your response to a mistake determines whether or not you will succeed in this new competitive environment. When mistakes are made, admit them – and then fix them. Acknowledge your own mistakes and your employees will acknowledge theirs as well. This will promote trust and encourage your employees to take risks. And don’t be afraid to talk about mistakes. In the past, too many companies considered sweeping mistakes under a rug to be a solution. Grab that rug, pick it up, and shake it out. Give your employees an opportunity to discuss lingering mistakes for learning and healing purposes, then move on. Both you and your employees will find that this is a great way to refresh your collective enthusiasm about the company and its strategies. Going forward, prepare a lessons-learned summary so you don’t make the same mistakes twice. Ensure that everyone has access to this summary and encourage employees to update it. Be prepared to deal with some delicate issues because mistake recognition/resolution must involve everyone – even you – or your employees will doubt the commitment to risk taking and quick decision-making. Hire good people, and don’t be afraid to admit that you can make mistakes in hiring. Moreover, don’t fall into the old trap of keeping bad hires to avoid recognizing your own mistakes. As one of my long-time officers has always said, “When a poor quality person shows up for work, it’s like two good employees calling in sick.” Rule #4 – Invest Wisely Economically justify every capital investment. You and your company probably aren’t operating under a protective regulatory umbrella anymore. Investments will not be guaranteed a return from captive customers. In fact, if you make a bad investment decision today, and it affects your customers tomorrow, they have a choice – they can choose your competitor’s energy and capacity. Always question, challenge, and understand every detail about your investments. You need to lead the way by following a stringent economic approval process. If an investment doesn’t meet your pre-established economic hurdles, it doesn’t get funded. End of discussion. This industry is top-heavy with capital and contrary to longstanding, utility industry belief, capital does have a cost. Tomorrow’s generation winners will be the participants who produce energy at the lowest possible cost, which generally translates into the smallest amount of invested capital, today. In an industry where competition is replacing monopolistic regulation, irrational pricing behaviors can emerge. This means that some of your competitors, in the short term, will sell their capacity and energy for less than their invested cost in order to maintain minimum levels of cash flow, even if it adversely impacts their financial ratios. You and your company, however, can’t get caught in a situation where you suffer losses because your capital costs have escalated. It’s easier to cut period costs than to reduce invested capital in an effort to remain financially viable, ignoring the obvious fact that capital cost reductions are a more arduous and lengthy process. The best advice is to adopt a “capital is scarce” attitude. Be a champion of rigorous economics on your plant investments, particularly on your aging facilities. Instill an intolerance for faulty analysis and poor economics when it comes to capital decisions. Standardize your investment decision methodologies. Ensure your management team understands why the methodologies are important and what the necessary investment hurdles are before a capital project goes forward. Rule #5 – Watch Your Costs Be a miser when it comes to General & Administrative expenses. It never ceases to amaze me how often executives forget that for every dollar of expense they incur, it’s one less dollar of earnings realized. The days of the cost-plus regulatory compact are long gone. We’re all accustomed to the PUC ensuring prudent spending of the ratepayers’ money. That’s not good enough in a competitive environment. You need to raise the bar even higher. Your employees and, most importantly, you should spend the company’s money as if it were your own. Sure, opportunities for meetings, conferences, and seminars in popular vacation spots will land on your desk. Think instead about ways to save the money it would cost to attend. Contact the organization to learn if it will post findings or minutes of the gathering on its website. Better yet, maybe the organization will conduct a webcast of the event. If you’re told “no,” suggest it to the organization’s public affairs or communications department. A lot of these organizations and their events can affect your company’s competitive edge by taking away your best people at the wrong time. It’s safe to say that you have a fair number of people assigned to various committees and strategic studies undertaken by groups using your sponsorship money, right? Evaluate the value proposition that these committees and studies offer your company. Think about ending your company’s membership if the cost/benefit ratio is negative. Guide your employees by your own actions. Involvement in these groups should be driven by clear indications of value that the company receives in exchange for its investment of time and/or money. As a leader, you must have the courage to cut ties to those organizations or initiatives that don’t measure up. In Conclusion I know what you’re thinking – you could add another five rules to my list. They could be just as valid as what I outlined. Hopefully, you have recognized the over-riding theme. It’s a common-sense, pragmatic style to leadership and management that we were all taught by our parents. It’s uncanny how the best leaders and their companies follow these simple rules of life: Be trustworthy, respectful, and caring Be results-focused and purposeful Be frugal Try these out. See how well your employees respond to the “new” you. They’re waiting for you to lead them, so lead. Filed under: White Papers Tagged under: Utilities About the Author Chris Trayhorn, Publisher of mThink Blue Book Chris Trayhorn is the Chairman of the Performance Marketing Industry Blue Ribbon Panel and the CEO of mThink.com, a leading online and content marketing agency. He has founded four successful marketing companies in London and San Francisco in the last 15 years, and is currently the founder and publisher of Revenue+Performance magazine, the magazine of the performance marketing industry since 2002.