The IBPP Revolution Meets – and Exceeds – Expectations by Chris Trayhorn, Publisher of mThink Blue Book, January 15, 2002 Introduction In an industry promising revolutionary advances nearly every day, one application has gone well beyond vision-speak: Internet bill presentment and payment(IBPP). By implementing an IBPP system, businesses can allow customers to view, store, and pay recurring bills using a Web browser, email, or personal financial management software. IBPP customers may also access and authorize payment via cellular or PDA wireless devices. Sophisticated IBPP systems will soon enable customers, particularly business customers, to analyze, dispute, and recalculate their bills prior to payment. The most obvious benefit to businesses is cost savings. “The most measurable savings will likely come through enhanced cash flow,” according to BancAmerica Robertson Stephens & Company, because the billing-cycle float is reduced. That involves not only mailing time, but also processing time and funds availability. Considering the additional savings in paper, handling, and postage (anywhere from $.50 to $1.50 per bill), and the overall improved efficiencies are reasons enough for any large business to implement IBPP. However, there are benefits that are even greater than cost-savings when businesses choose the most appropriate IBPP solution for their customers. More than half of the approximately 18 billion bills sent annually will be available online by 2002, according to some market research. Some analysts have even gone so far as to predict the outright failure of businesses that don’t implement IBPP. That’s why many corporations are currently evaluating or implementing IBPP solutions, including hundreds of firms in the financial services, telecommunications, and utility sectors — where bills can number from hundreds of thousands to multiple millions each month. Solution models are still evolving, but any successful model must be completely flexible to accommodate the rapidly evolving needs of customers. IBPP Benefit Overview The traditional approach to billing a customer involved very little interaction with the customer. Viewed as a non-strategic cost center, the billing department was often isolated from the customer service area of the company and devoted only to payment collection. However, in today’s Web–driven business environment — where delivering the highest levels of customer care is essential to long-term success — this approach has proven inadequate. By actively engaging the customer in the billing process, IBPP can facilitate world-class customer care and transform billing into a competitive edge for the billing company. The benefits are vital for companies taking their business to the Web: Customer Care and Relationship Management IBPP brings greater efficiency to the billing process and generates stronger customer loyalty by providing better service. Today’s most robust IBPP solutions not only provide a new vehicle for viewing and paying bills, but also a better way to submit bill disputes and commonly asked questions. This helps free the customer service staff from time-consuming and costly telephone-based support. Customers can receive email responses to their questions, while the customer care staff uses its time more efficiently by handling more urgent and complex issues. IBPP can strengthen the relationships that a large biller has with its small and medium-sized business customers by streamlining business processes and building customer loyalty. This can be achieved without requiring the installation and maintenance of expensive Electronic Data Interchange systems. Large companies have traditionally employed proprietary EDI invoicing and payment systems to manage online purchasing and invoicing with large business customers. These EDI solutions have required expensive customized software and additional hardware to be installed, maintained, and upgraded at each user’s site. The expense of these EDI systems has been too great for most smaller customers, leaving them to grapple with more cumbersome processes. With Web access to IBPP, the high level of service that large customers have enjoyed from EDI solutions can be extended to smaller business customers at a lower cost. Even large customers can take advantage of additional services offered through IBPP without modification to their current EDI systems. Highly Targeted Marketing While serving customers more efficiently, IBPP also offers a biller the opportunity to gather market intelligence about customers in real-time. Based on customer profiles, companies can deliver graphically rich “enclosures” and other dynamically generated promotional content for their customers. Marketing programs can be tailored to an individual’s preference. Innovative companies are initiating or extending their e-commerce offerings by using IBPP to enable customers to establish new services and order products online. A tremendous advantage of IBPP is the demographic type of customer that it attracts. In the consumer market, early IBPP adopters are likely to be well-educated and have high disposable incomes. These ideal prospects also have a high probability of becoming early adopters of other new products and services the biller might offer, whether directly or in conjunction with a business partner. Enhanced Revenue Generation In addition to new marketing opportunities, IBPP offers new opportunities for revenue generation. For example, large billers eager to attract customers to their sites are hosting other companies’ bills in order to offer customers convenient, one-stop bill payment. They see value in increased usage and receive a larger audience for their own services. Banks that maintain their own online banking services are in a particularly strong position to offer IBPP services to other companies. Telecommunications companies are also in various stages of evaluating this opportunity. Business models for consolidation based on presentment and transaction fees promise a significant source of new revenue. As IBPP becomes established, there will be opportunities for well-branded bill payment sites to sell advertising space as well. Implementation Options Simply put, IBPP means using the Internet to deliver recurring bills — and options for paying them — through a Web browser interface. But there are other methods of implementing IBPP, and different types of partners that can help businesses integrate IBPP by taking on critical functions in an outsourcing capacity. Direct Model In the direct model, a biller uses its corporate Web site to present bills to customers and/or send bill summary notices via email. Payers must visit the Web site to review bill summaries and details. They may then pay the bill, often through a third-party payment provider. Unlike a retail bank or originating depository financial institution, the TPPP simply processes bill payment and collects a transaction fee. Figure 1 illustrates the interaction between the biller, customer, and TPPP. After the customer enrolls for electronic billing (Step 1), the biller emails a notification to the customer (Step 2), which might contain bill summary information. The customer can then view bill details at the biller’s Web site (Step 3), as well as authorize payments (Step 4). Once authorized, a payment is processed by the TPPP, who debits the customer’s account and sends a remittance to the biller (Step 5). Figure 1 – In the direct IBPP model, the biller establishes a one-on-one relationship with the customer. The direct model enables a biller to maintain full control of the display of bills, additional services, and marketing content. It also allows the biller to preserve in-house control of important customer profiles and billing data. Strategically, the direct model of IBPP can also serve as a test case for advanced customer relationship management solutions. As businesses recognize the strategic importance of CRM services such as customer self-care, they’re looking for extensible, customer-centered applications that attract and retain customers. With IBPP as a foundation, businesses can implement scalable billing systems to provide the best in 21st Century customer care. Many consumers have already experienced some form of direct billing, usually from credit card companies or telecommunications providers. While the eventual dominance of consolidated models (discussed below) seems assured, the strength of such models will rest on a direct-billing infrastructure. For example, many customers will continue to want to contact a biller directly to obtain customer care or to take advantage of targeted marketing initiatives. And business customers — who typically require bill analysis and invoice negotiation — will appreciate a direct relationship with their major suppliers. Only a flexible IBPP system will allow the simultaneous implementation of the direct model with other models for a full range of customer benefits. Consolidation Model True market momentum lies with the consolidation model of IBPP. In this model, the biller sends billing data to a third party, known as a bill consolidator. The consolidator aggregates data from multiple billers and prepares bills for presentment through its third-party arrangements with financial institutions or Internet portals. Customers can then access their bills from the bill consolidation site and enjoy the convenience of one-stop bill presentment. Within the framework of this model, two distinct types of bill consolidators are emerging: “thick” and “thin” consolidators. Thick consolidation — In the thick consolidator model, the biller sends all of its billing data, including transaction details, to the third-party bill consolidator. All customer interaction is managed by the consolidator, which acts as a single point of contact for the customer to manage multiple bills. Figure 2 illustrates the interaction between the biller, consolidator, customer, and TPPP in the thick consolidator model. Figure 2 – Thick consolidators offer customers a one-stop shopping experience for reviewing and authorizing bills from multiple billers. When the customer enrolls with the bill consolidator (Step 1), the bill consolidator registers that customer with each biller for whom the customer has requested electronic billing (Step 2). The biller then forwards billing data to the consolidator at regular intervals (Step 3) where it is consolidated into a single billing database. Customers are notified by the bill consolidator whenever they have bills to review from any biller (Step 4). The customer can view bill details and authorize payments (Steps 5 and 6) at the bill consolidator’s Web site. Payment processing transactions between the bill consolidator and the TPPP (Step 7) result in a remittance to the biller (Step 8). Thick consolidators offer customers a one-stop shopping experience for reviewing and authorizing bills from multiple billers. However, because traditional thick consolidators do not provide direct interaction with the customer, the biller has limited control over customer relationship management and targeted marketing. Thin consolidation — Thin consolidators combine the strengths of the direct billing model and thick consolidation model by collecting and preparing only bill summary information. Customers that request billing details are linked from the consolidation site directly to the specific biller’s Web site, enabling the biller to directly provide extended customer care and targeted marketing. This hybrid approach allows billers to achieve the broad reach of consolidation while retaining direct interaction with the customer for control over strategic marketing initiatives and customer relationship management. Figure 3 illustrates the interaction between the various parties in a thin consolidator model. Figure 3 – Thin consolidators combine the strengths of both direct billing and thick consolidators. Here, enrollment (Steps 1 and 2) is handled by the thin consolidator, who transparently enrolls the customer with each biller they’ve selected. Unlike the thick consolidator model, where the biller sends full billing details to the consolidator (and also defers the opportunity for a one-to-one electronic connection with its customer), here the biller sends only bill summary information to the consolidator (Step 3). Email notification alerts the customer (Step 4) that bill summary information is available for viewing on the consolidator’s Web site (Step 5). If the customer would like to view full billing details, they are routed securely to the biller’s Web site without having to log on again. At the biller’s site, the customer can view bill details (Step 6) and see any other information the biller chooses to make available, such as targeted marketing and customer care information. The customer returns to the bill consolidator’s site to authorize payment (Step 7). Payment processing and remittance to the biller (Steps 8 and 9) are then handled by a TPPP or through the biller’s financial institution relationship. Like the thick consolidator model, this approach has the requirement of a highly reliable and scalable solution that can handle large transaction volumes at the consolidator. However, this model also requires that the biller’s Web site support the detailed transactions of IBPP as well as all of the components of customer care and marketing. Biller and Consumer Service Providers Businesses that implement IBPP solutions may look to other vendors to outsource critical functions of the overall solution. To help with specific IBPP requirements, two key players have emerged: Biller Service Providers and Consumer Service Providers. BSPs offer outsourcing of IBPP services to billers such as local telephone companies and utilities. They manage the information technology systems, the billing data, and the electronic payment transactions on a service basis. BSPs may implement the direct billing model or be part of a consolidation solution. In either case, they serve multiple billers, thus generating economies of scale. CSPs focus on the consumer, presenting bill summary information from multiple billers to the customer. Since customers often have relationships with geographically dispersed billers, the convenience of the CSP’s one-stop Web site, where they can authorize multiple bill payments, is compelling. The CSP model is particularly compelling for retail banks and enterprises in certain vertical industries. Conclusion The combination of leading-edge IBPP with state-of-the-art online customer care is recasting customer relationships and increasing customer loyalty. IBPP transforms billing into a strategic marketing vehicle, tailored to a customer’s unique profile and allowing the cross-selling of a company’s services and products. Industries experiencing intense competition with their products and services, such as financial institutions, telecommunications companies, and utilities, can differentiate themselves with IBPP services and are aggressively pursuing IBPP solutions. Banks in particular are in a unique position to become direct billers and bill presenters for other companies, as well as key electronic payment players. Ultimately, IBPP will transform the bill presentment and payment process even further. Features such as bill reporting, search and analysis capability and bill history all promise to simplify the billing process. As IBPP evolves, today’s batch-mode process will be replaced with real-time billing that is truly customer-driven. For example, user-defined direct debit — the authorization of automatic payments based on predetermined criteria — could eliminate the need for customers to track and individually pay bills that fit their specifications. Customers will be able to see their account status at any time and control how and when they receive and pay their bills. For More Information iPlanet E-Commerce Solutions delivers a comprehensive IBPP solution tailored to the needs of billers. Built on the scalable foundation of the iPlanet Application Server, iPlanet BillerXpert and iPlanet BillerXpert, Consolidator Edition applications support large-scale, transaction-intensive Web sites. Whether a company presents bills directly or via consolidators or Internet portals, the iPlanet commitment to open standards helps ensure that its IBPP solution will link to all the key constituencies in the presentment and payment infrastructure, and reach customers via every Internet-ready device. To learn more about the iPlanet IBPP solution, please visit the Billerxpert product pages at www.iplanet.com. Sales contact information can be obtained by contacting iPlanet headquarters in Santa Clara, California at 888.786.8111. Related reading materials can also be found at: www.sun.com/sp/suntone and www.sun.com/sp/sunconnect Filed under: White Papers Tagged under: Utilities About the Author Chris Trayhorn, Publisher of mThink Blue Book Chris Trayhorn is the Chairman of the Performance Marketing Industry Blue Ribbon Panel and the CEO of mThink.com, a leading online and content marketing agency. He has founded four successful marketing companies in London and San Francisco in the last 15 years, and is currently the founder and publisher of Revenue+Performance magazine, the magazine of the performance marketing industry since 2002.